Thursday, April 26, 2007

Thoughts on homeschooling an only child

I'll not link to the post that has got a few of my fellow "homeschoolers of onlies" upset, but suffice to say that there are other homeschoolers out there who think onlies should never be homeschooled. My own one-and-only is an only by our choice. I know other one child families who are so by choice and others who may have wanted more than one, but are one child families nonetheless. No matter how a family comes to be a one child family, they have the right to be left to own lives without judgment upon the fact of their onlyhood.

In my extended family, there are no other onlies. We're the freaks of the family anyway, (Dh is a pagan. I'm a witch. We're both Marxists. And so on and so on...) so our chosen onlyhood is just more grist for the mill to our detractors. Frankly, we don't give a flying fuckerolie what they think. It does get tedious, however, to hear the same old tired phrases.

"He must be lonely."

"Aren't you going to give him a little brother or sister?"

"Why don't you want to give him a little brother or sister?"

"What do you mean, you don't want to give him a little brother or sister?"

"I'll bet he's just begging for a sibling all the time, isn't he?"

"That [onlyhood] is so sad."

"Miscarriages?"
This one is always whispered with a sad tone, which if I had suffered miscarriages, I would find not only intrusive, but hurtful and patronizing as well.

Some people will say that they think onlies are spoiled. They usually have no more than random anecdotal evidence to support this claim. They are never people who actually have an only. Of course, I have only my own experience to draw from on what an only child is like, and then, I only have my own child to reference.

In our world, T is probably the centre. Unpopular as this idea may be among my acquaintances IRL, I'm not interested in where my so-called career is going during this chapter of my life. I'm not interested in being super-woman. I couldn't care less what other women think I should be doing right now. I have chosen to give this chapter of my life totally, completely and quite willingly to raising my child. Daycare doesn't raise him. School doesn't raise him. I, and my dh, do. That includes educating him as well.

L, my husband, once pointed out that "we have the luxury of being a small family." I do indeed think of it as a luxury. We don't have to juggle the schedules of multiple children, nor shoulder the expense of added children, nor deal with issues of sibling rivalry. I admire women and families who deal with these things with joy and success, but that isn't us. That isn't what we chose. I'm not in competition to be mother of the year. Our life is not a competition.

As for homeschooling an only, we find that we have a lot of luxury there, too. Everything is truly one on one -- sometimes even two on one. We don't have to worry if the curriculum we've chosen will work with multiple ages, learning styles, personalities, etc. We don't have to wonder if we're devoted equal (and enough) time to each child.

Oh, sure, there are drawbacks, too. That's life. My point, however, is that we do just fine, thank you very much. Don't feel sorry for me. Don't feel sorry for my son. We certainly don't feel sorry for ourselves. But, also, don't tell us what we can and can't do based upon some uninformed, inexperienced, irrelevant opinion you happen to have pulled out your ass.

8 comments:

JoVE said...

Well said. The worst comment I ever had (from my own mother) was "Do you regret that your brother was ever born?" Needless to say I just ignored that one as I try to do with all the subsequent bullying to have another child. We're doing fine, too. And homeschooling suits her down to the ground. Much better than school did.

Kate in NJ said...

I really enjoyed this post.
I am also tired of people asking me
when we will have another,and acting like we should be worried about her feeling like she is the center of our universe.
Notice I said "our" and not "the".
Good to know I am not alone.

Frankie said...

I agree with Jove -- well said. That original post has pissed me off ever since I read it -- I think it just touched on a very raw nerve.

I was very impressed with your comments to the original post -- you kept your cool.

"jew" "girl" said...

what a great post! I thoroughly enjoyed it and love your attitude, not that you care ;).

I'm a single dame in my thirties with no children and still on the fence about reproducing. to some degree, I can relate. I get the what's wrong with you? how can you not know if you want kids?, etc. etc.

it's all so thoroughly fascinating. and, how exhausting it must be to feel like you have to live your life the way others want you to.

oy vey, who has the koyouch for it, ya know!

ps: thanks for stopping by my blog. I'm so happy you did. I really like your blogs, you pagen goddess you!

Crimson Wife said...

People can be so nosy and rude, whatever family size one has. It just blows my mind what certain individuals will say. There is no "right" number of children for a family, just whatever the couple decides is best for them given their own personal circumstances (whether that's 0, 1, or 2+). My ideal would be a larger family, but it's not my place to judge someone who makes a different choice.

Thanks for sharing this!

mar said...

This is exactly us, too. Thank you so much for writing it.

titusa said...

Geez, if you didn't live in Canada I would have thought you were me! I'm also a librarian, homeschooling my only child, and a practicing witch and pagan. Separated at birth??
This is my first time reading your blog - I'll be back!

mrsb said...

Why would anyone think any of that (or your reasons for it) was any of their business?